About Our Church
First Presbyterian Church of Bethlehem is a warm community of faith with an
expansive welcome. We’re part of the Presbyterian Church (USA) and
Lehigh Presbytery. We pride ourselves on trying new things
to deepen our worship experiences,
nurture intergenerational relationships, cultivate spiritual growth, and
build meaningful connections to create change in our community.
Mission Statement
Congregational Core Values
Christ-Centered
In everything we do, we strive to follow Jesus Christ faithfully through the authority and insight of God’s Word and Spirit,
to imitate Christ in how we treat others.
Expansively Welcoming
Because our unity is in Christ, we strive to be a community of Christian faith where people of all backgrounds, identities, and orientations are welcomed, supported, engaged, and empowered in their individual faith and our common life
and ministry. We affirm LGBTQ+ individuals and celebrate their full participation in the life and leadership of the church.
An Inquiring Faith
Following Christ’s example in Scripture, we believe that curiosity and questioning are essential practices of faith, and that some of our most important work as a congregation is helping each other to ask better questions about faith and life,
and to seek more faithful answers together.
An Active Faith
We believe faith is not simply a set of beliefs, but a way of life. Faith is lived out in the daily practice of those beliefs through concrete actions of love, justice, mercy, kindness, repentance, reconciliation, and peace.
Who We Are
Leadership
First Presbyterian Church of Bethlehem is a ‘member-driven’ church, and as such depends
on the talents, time and commitment of numerous lay leaders. Along with a dedicated staff,
they assure that this congregation continues to grow and thrive.
Rev. Karen Kinney
Transitional Pastor
Karen has long been interested in helping people and organizations thrive through her professional and personal relationships. Known as the Ann Landers of her crew in high school, she took that role seriously, listening deeply to concerns, fears and hopes, asking hard questions, and guiding folks to discern a path forward.
In her previous 30-year nonprofit career, Karen worked with hundreds of organizations through raising money, recommending grants, helping build their capacity to deliver services and programs, and creating coalitions to work on housing, economic development, and racial justice among others. She says one of her favorite parts of the job was the privilege of hearing people’s dreams and helping make them reality.
For the last 10+ years, Karen has been an ordained Teaching Elder in the PCUSA. She finally said yes to the call to ministry and seminary in 2006, graduating from Wesley Theological Seminary (there’s a story there – ask her) in 2013 and ordained and installed in 2014.
Karen carried her commitment to listening to dreams and hopes, connecting to the community, and building the capacity for churches to be loved in their communities by spreading the Gospel message far and wide into her work as a pastor. She is an ecumenical (she’s been Methodist and Baptist), and interfaith voice having experienced the value of working together across boundaries to bring understanding and the desire to work together with and on behalf of those who are too often “otherized.”
The proud mother of two adult children, in her spare time Karen likes to read and watch murder mysteries (not the super violent kind…), be with friends and family, visit the ocean and go to the mountains. She often says that being born in West Virginia means mountains are part of her DNA providing a place of joy, rest and renewal.
Karen most recently wrapped up a year-long position as the Merger Coordinator for the Lehigh and Lackawanna presbyteries. Before that, she was the designated pastor of Christ Presbyterian Church of the Slate Belt in Roseto, PA.
Rev. Lindsey Altvater Clifton
Associate Pastor for Justice and Community Impact
Lindsey is a self-proclaimed nerd who enjoys life’s simple pleasures: hammocks, a good book, playing outside, Vietnamese iced coffee, laughing until it hurts, kayaking, board games, ice cream, and writing liturgy. Before being called to serve at First Pres in March of 2021, she served as Co-Pastor of Forest Hills Presbyterian Church in High Point, NC.
She was born and raised in Greensboro, NC, and is an alum of Elon University (B.A., 2009) and Wake Forest University (M.Div. 2016). Her faith journey has been rather ecumenical (ask her about it sometime), so she has served as a lay leader and staff person in a few denominational traditions. She also taught high school English for four years (and loved it!) before going to divinity school. These experiences have taught her the value of curiosity and openness, humility and playfulness.
Since her ordination in 2017, Lindsey has served on the Executive Council and the Committee on Representation in Salem Presbytery. She was a planning team member and primary worship leader for the Southeast Regional Festival of Young Preachers (Academy of Preachers) in 2018 and the Presbyterians for Earth Care Annual Conference in 2019. Lindsey also had the privilege of being a Teaching Associate for the Introduction to Homiletics course at WFU’s School of Divinity in 2018.
Lindsey is happily getting to know the Lehigh Valley with her wife, Laura, and their sweet, goofy dog, Maggie, and new puppy, Augie. She enjoys learning about new spiritual practices and exploring them with others. Lindsey is passionate about creative intergenerational ministry and community engagement, faith formation and missional outreach. She loves worship planning and preaching, and she finds joy in helping folks of all ages connect to the life of the church – both within the congregation and in the wider community. And she’d love to have coffee or lunch with you sometime!
Rev. Suzanne Trump
Pastoral Associate for Compassion
Suzanne was born and raised in the Lehigh Valley and now lives in Fogelsville. She graduated from Easton Area High School and Temple University with a degree in Occupational Therapy.
A lifelong Lutheran she was encouraged at an early age to pursue a call to ministry, but it was not until she meet a female pastor that she could see herself as a pastor. So, after a few years of practicing occupational therapy she entered the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia, now Union Lutheran Seminary and graduated with a Master of Divinity in 1992.
Still not quite sure that she was called to ordained ministry, Suzanne returned to practicing OT and taught at the University of the Sciences in Philadelphia. At the university her career track changed to include chairing the academic advising center and the student success initiatives. She also completed a Master of Religion at Temple University.
Still feeling a call to ministry, she was ordained in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America in 2007, which is not the longest time between seminary completion and ordination in the Lutheran church, but close to it! Suzanne served Grace Lutheran Church in Allentown and St. John’s Windish Lutheran Church in Bethlehem. And upon retiring from the Lutheran church, she joined First Presbyterian Church of Bethlehem in April of 2023.
Suzanne is an avid golfer, often playing at the Bethlehem Golf Course, and enjoys several forms of exercise including talking walks with her German Shepard dog Fiona. She spends free time serving as a chaplain and scholarship committee co-chair for the Lehigh Valley Military Affairs Council and serves as a committee member for She Nailed It for Habitat for Humanity Lehigh valley.
She is passionate about helping a people to live out their call as Christians in the world. She is deeply concerned with making sure that everyone has stable housing, nourishing food to eat and the opportunity to live their best life.
Suzanne was married to a former Vietnam and Med-evac pilot, Doug, who entered the church triumphant several years ago. Her mother and her brother and his wife all live in the Lehigh Valley. And although she is too young, she has seven grandchildren and three (step)children from her marriage to Doug.
David Macbeth
Director of Music Ministries
David serves as the Director of Music Ministries and Choirmaster at First Presbyterian Church of Bethlehem.
He leads our Chancel Choir and directs the music for both traditional and contemporary services.
A founding member of the faculty at the Lehigh Valley Charter High School of the Arts, David is vocal department artistic director, conducts three of the school’s five choral ensembles, and teaches classes in advanced placement (AP) music theory, music history, keyboarding, and applied vocal techniques.
David holds undergraduate and graduate degrees in music education, vocal performance and choral conducting from Westchester University. He minored in piano and organ performance and graduated magna cum laude.
While at Westchester, David was awarded numerous merit and performance scholarships. In 2013, he achieved the American Guild of Organists Choir Master certification, ranking third nationally among that year’s applicants.
In 2015 David was awarded a choral conducting fellowship with the Yale School of Music Norfolk Chamber Music Festival, studying advanced choral conducting under Simon Carrington. He has conducted choral ensembles at such world-class venues as New York’s Carnegie Hall, the National Cathedral in Washington, DC., King’s Chapel, Boston, and the Dome Cathedral, Riga, Latvia.
Session
The Session is comprised of twelve Elders, who are nominated and elected annually by the church membership and serve as the decision-making body of the church. They recommend and approve all program and policy implementation and modifications in the church. These standing committees have been established by Session:
- Finance
- Endowment
- Nominating
- Personnel
- Worship
- Community Life Program
The Elders are elected for a term of three years; the current slate of Elders (and their term’s year of expiration) are:
Jennifer Cole, Clerk of Session
Rev. Karen Kinney, Moderator
Class of 2025:
Jon Conrad
Linda Filipovits
Ted Masthay
Aileen Williams
Class of 2026:
Kari Keyock
Kim Miner
Rich Hjorth
JoAnne Turcotte
Class of 2027:
Jennifer Cole
Melody Engel
Allison Masters
Donna Taggart
Deacons
The Deacons are the caregivers of the church, ordained lay members of the congregation who are best described as the church’s ‘ministers of mercy.’ They minister to the individual members through home communion and visits, hospital and prayer ministries, and providing support to those in difficult situations. Deacons are under the supervision and authority of the Session.
The Deacons are elected for a term of three years; those currently serving (and their term’s year of expiration) are:
Jane Masters, Moderator
Rev. Suzane M. Trump, Pastoral Associate for Compassion, Staff
Class of 2025:
Debbie Castellano
Marie Rosenthal
Doreen Sheppard
Class of 2026:
Kate Arrington
Evelyn Kuserk
Phyllis Walker
Jane Masters
Class of 2027:
Sue Jones
Jane Mackie
Bette Maiatico
Susan Oeschle
Trustees
Trustees oversee all financial and property matters in the church including the budget, building renovations and repairs, planned giving, and investment funds. Trustees meet monthly and members also serve on one additional committee, such as the property or finance committee, which also generally meet monthly.
The Trustees are elected for a term of three years; the current slate of Trustees (and their term’s year of expiration) are:
Richard Gorton, President
Cynthia Hahn, Vice-President
Class of 2025:
Sue Nelson
Bud Newton
Jack Walker
Class of 2026:
George Bickford
Rich Gorton
Cynthia Hahn
Class of 2027:
Sheldon Cooper
Janet Luther
Ginger Seifried
Let's Connect!
Mail:
2344 Center Street
Bethlehem, PA 18017
Contact Us:
610-867-5865
info@fpc-bethlehem.org
Media Inquiries:
Carol Burns
Communications Manager
610-867-5865, ext. 238
Email Us:
Transitional Pastor: Rev. Karen Kinney
Associate Pastor for Justice and Community Impact:
Rev. Lindsey Altvater Clifton
Pastoral Associate for Compassion:
Rev. Suzanne Trump
Director of Music Ministries: David Macbeth
Director of Church Administration: David Crook
Weekday Preschool Director: Tracy Leszcynski
Rentals/Facility Usage: Carol Burns
Facilities Maintenance Manager: Kevin Konczyk